For a long time now social and economic investment has been viewed and undertaken quite separately. And yes, I completely understand the argument for separating investment in people from investment in business – different focus, different activity, different outcomes. I believe, however, that it is time to look again at the two and to begin to treat them more as a partnership.
This is particularly important for our district where many of our communities struggle on both levels. We need to recognise that these two investment strands are strongly interlinked. My argument is that one does not flourish without the other. There are numerous examples of social deprivation impacting on economic opportunities. You just have to look at the fruit picking industry and the fact that people are brought in from overseas to work, although there are plenty here in need of a job. There should be no mistake that there is a LOT of social investment coming into the Far North from government and other agencies. It is arguable how much of it is actually making a difference to the challenges that many residents face. I have for some time pondered on what can motivate the more challenged ‘clients’ to participate in the opportunities that are available. One reason for this disengagement I would argue is a lack of aspiration or, dare I say, a lack of hope: what reason is there for getting out of bed in the morning? And, if we are honest, there is a deep-down belief that many carry, that they are not worthy or valuable. So my question is, what if government-supported, economic-investment in the Far North had to meet much wider social-impact criteria and not just commercial outcomes (noting that more jobs is always a good thing). So, how might this work? Here’s one idea: in communities where there is heavy social investment*, we should also look at developing inspirational economic opportunities that in turn, provide a catalyst for change. We could develop facilities that are beautiful structures in their own right, that celebrate the people and the place they exist in. These will be training grounds, hosting entrepreneurial activities that provide a unique and valued addition to the economy. They could be set-up as social enterprises with a commercial focus, so that profits go back into the communities that support them. Imagine having a commercial activity that the locals feel connected to, are proud of and benefit from. If we are to make real change for a better tomorrow here in the Far North, we need to move past the reasons of why it’s too hard and instead adopt a ‘yes we can’ default attitude. We need to empower the people. And we certainly need to see that all things are interconnected. The possibilities of our potential are boundless – we just need to believe. * It should be noted, that government-supported, social investment should also look to be balanced with economic investment.
4 Comments
9/7/2017 07:54:52 am
This is what social (I prefer to call it community) enterprise is all about Tanya. There are many examples of this thought the Far North with Kaitaia's CBEC being a shining example and several worthy start-ups that commenced following the Far North Thrive programmed. Russell Recyclers www.russell recyclers.nz is a good example of this. However, what is urgently needed for these enterprises to succeed in creating positive impact in our communities, is far more Council support and less departmental red tape.
Reply
Tania McInnes
9/7/2017 08:15:46 am
Thanks John for your thoughts. I agree :)
Reply
Rachael Gilbert
9/7/2017 08:40:54 am
With the greatest respect would you be willing to live off the wage picking fruit gives? A backpacker can because they have minimal overheads, a cheap dorm room and living off noodles and it's all part of an adventure. They don't have a whanau to raise, car to run, uniforms to buy etc. But none of those individuals would go home and say, hell yeah, this is how I want to support my family day in day out! Infact most of my backpacking friends stuck their head down and did it for three months to get an extension to their working holiday visa, that was their main motivation.
Reply
Tania McInnes
9/7/2017 09:10:35 am
Thanks Rachel for your thoughtful response. I am a huge fan of community empowerment and agree there is much to be challenged if we are to move forward for the betterment of all.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorTania McInnes. Archives
January 2024
Categories |